Backstory
The idea for “Wishing Well” came from the heartbreaking side of loving someone deeply enough to finally accept that they may not choose you back. I wanted to write a song about the kind of love that is mature enough to let go, even when it hurts.
The title came from the image of a wishing well — a place where someone keeps throwing hope, prayers, and quiet wishes into the dark, hoping one day they might come true. In this song, the narrator has spent so much time wishing for that person to be theirs, only to realize the most loving thing left to do is wish them happiness, even if that happiness is with someone else.
At its heart, “Wishing Well” is about heartbreak without bitterness. It is about loving someone enough to release them, while still carrying the weight of what you hoped life could have been. I wanted it to feel honest, emotional, and devastating in a quiet way — the kind of song where the final wish is not for yourself anymore, but for the person you still love.
Lyrics
Song: Wishing Well (Wishing You Well)
Demo/Pitch Version
BMI
Verse 1
Just beyond the picket fence,
through the tall sweet grass,
Down the old dirt path
where the fireflies used to pass,
There sat a mossy well
at the edge of the wood,
You'd reach for my hand
like you always would.
Seven years old
with our pockets full of wishes,
Your mama's coins,
my mama's Sunday kisses,
You'd throw yours in laughin',
never tell a soul,
I'd close my eyes
and wish you were my whole world.
Pre-Chorus
The water never answered,
but Lord, it heard it all
Every quiet prayer
I made during the fall.
Chorus
From the wishing well,
I wished on you.
Dropped every coin,
I had into the deep dark blue.
I Wished you'd see me,
like I saw you standing there,
Boy-next-door
with the tangled hair.
Now I'm at the well again,
older and alone,
Still wishing you well,
though you're someone's home.
From a wishing well
to wishing you well
Verse 2
Junior year, midnight,
your truck in my drive,
Flowers on my wrist,
something stirrin' alive,
Prom night glitter
still caught in my hair.
You said, "One last walk,
I know just where."
We stood at that well,
in the moon's silver light.
Your jacket on my shoulders,
my heart taking flight.
I threw my token slow,
made the same old wish.
Prayed that you could feel,
what lived in all of this.
You drove me home quiet,
the radio low,
And the well kept our secret.
You just didn't know.
Pre-Chorus
The water never answered,
but Lord, it heard it all.
Every quiet prayer I made,
before the fall.
Chorus
From the wishing well,
I wished on you.
Dropped every coin,
I had into the deep dark blue.
I Wished you'd see me,
like I saw you standing there,
Boy-next-door
with the tangled hair.
Now I'm at the well again,
older and alone,
Still wishing you well,
though you're someone's home.
From a wishing well
to wishing you well
Bridge
Maybe the well,
was never mine to keep.
Maybe some wishes,
are meant to sink deep.
Resting at the bottom,
like they belong.
Beautiful and quiet,
Causing no harm.
Verse 3
Church bells ringin',
on the east side of town.
White dress in a window,
her veil coming down.
Everyone who loves you,
dressed in their best.
And I'm at the well again,
hand on my chest.
No flowers, no pennies,
just me and the moss.
Tallying up everything,
tender I've lost.
The creek running soft,
like it's trying to say.
Baby girl, let it go,
it's his wedding day.
Pre-Chorus
So I reach in my pocket,
one coin left to spend,
Don't wish for a beginning,
just wish him a happy end.
To every old wound,
and every hard night.
I close my eyes and I wish him,
a beautiful life.
Final Chorus
From the wishing well,
I wished on you.
Dropped every coin,
I had into the deep dark blue.
I Wished you'd see me,
like I saw you standing there,
boy-next-door
with the tangled hair.
Now I'm at the well again,
older and alone,
Still wishing you well,
though you're someone's home.
From a wishing well
to wishing you well
Outro
(soft, like a whisper to the water)
From a wishing well… to wishing you well.
I'm wishing you well.